Website Conversion Killers Your Business Can Avoid

Website Conversion Killers Your Business Can Avoid

Rankings are up, website visits are up, you’re listed in the local online directories — it looks like your SEO efforts are paying off. More people are finding your website through organic search. Internet life is good!

But for some reason, leads are flat. People are coming to your website, but they aren’t converting to revenue-generating business.

Poor conversion can destroy even the best marketing efforts. If you are making an investment in bringing visitors to your website, it should be generating leads. And not just any leads, quality ones that generate new business for your company. Leads that can become high-value clients, not leads you have to turn away. 

Our experienced and skilled team at Propel Business Solutions have identified a few website conversion killers that are a “must watch” — and a “must fix” — so you can be sure to generate new quality leads for your business. 

1. Are your forms working? Look out for malfunctioning forms or forms that are difficult to complete.

Forms are a quick and easy way to collect contact information from potential clients. People who are not comfortable picking up a phone and calling or who are strapped for time will often be willing to fill out a quick form. Businesses that have found ways to make the Internet work for them and are developing quality leads and new revenue, almost always have a convenient form on most pages of their websites. 

Several issues will cause visitors to abandon a form. What are the top three most common issues? 

    1.    Technical errors

    2.    Form length

    3.    Types of questions being asked

To address technical errors, it’s important to test forms regularly to ensure they are working and visitors are able to submit easily.  It’s even a good idea to try and break the form by filling out fields incorrectly or leaving a required field blank. If visitors are entering information incorrectly, are they being shown an obvious error message that outlines how to fix the problem and correctly submit the form? Are required fields clearly marked? Are form notifications being sent to the right email address? 

In addition to being technically sound, your forms should be easy to complete. The longer a form, the higher the risk of abandonment. Identify the information you absolutely need to pursue a lead and ask only for those things. Remember, website visitors are generally comfortable entering details like “name” and “email,” but they may balk at filling in more personal details like a phone number or address. 

2. Are your lead generators placed in the right area on the site? Watch out for Banner Blindness.

Banner Blindness is a phenomenon where people ignore content they believe to be an advertisement. For example, ads are commonly placed in a sidebar area on the right-hand side of a page. Because people are used to seeing ads in this area, they may ignore legitimate content because it looks like an ad. Pictures that serve as navigation, particularly if they are sized and placed in areas of a page where people are accustomed to seeing ads, may be lost to visitors. 

Banner Blindness also affects auto-rotating header carousels. Multiple user studies including one from the Nielsen Norman Group, reveal people often do not see the messages contained in rotating banner images. Visitors may ignore this feature because they assume they are trying to be sold something or they may simply not get to see the part of the slideshow that would most interest them. Research has also shown that when an auto-rotating slideshow is replaced with a static image, conversions increase. 

3. Is your content unique and useful? Watch out for Content Blindness.

Internet users (that is, most people) can also be trained to ignore content that is predictable, generic or overly salesy. Your page content, particularly on high-traffic practice area pages, must go beyond the boilerplate verbiage like “legal issues are complicated, we can help” followed by a bulleted list of services. 

People who are researching a legal problem may come to your website at various stages in their hiring process. Some may not yet realize they need a lawyer and are just looking for information. Others may be looking for an attorney for a specific issue and need to find someone they feel they can trust. And, of course, there are many stages and situations in between. 

Presenting useful, instructive content at various stages within the decision- making process will help prevent content blindness, keep new visitors on your website longer and encourage conversions. 

4. Are you using keywords correctly? Watch out for Keyword Disparity.

People who land on one of your pages after having searched for a specific keyword or phrase should find information relevant to that phrase. If there is a discrepancy between the answers your page provides and the questions visitors have asked to get there, they will click away. 

For attorneys, this means you should be putting the bulk of your SEO efforts into your most lucrative services. Ranking highly for many terms is not helpful if the people searching for those terms aren’t’t viable — or valuable — leads. 

5. Are you giving potential leads the information they want? Watch out for Unanswered Questions.

When a website is attempting to promote a complex product or service, as a law firm website often can be, visitors need to understand what they are purchasing before they are willing to make a commitment. If a visitor leaves your site feeling like he or she doesn’t really know what you do or what can be expected from the process, that visitor is not likely to become a lead. 

One way to address this problem is to use the theory of separation of concerns. Websites designed according to this principle break content up into small pieces, each of which describes a single aspect of the product or service. This both helps visitors understand the service and it presents information in a way that helps them scan the page and find the sections that specifically address their uncertainty. 

A robust site search is another way to ensure visitors’ questions are being answered. You may have multiple pages and blog posts about a topic, maybe even a video or two, but if visitors can’t access them these resources are wasted. Be sure your site search is easy to find and provides relevant results. 

6. Is your website designed for functionality? Watch out for poor visual direction and non-specific calls to action.

Functional design and pretty design are different things. Pretty designs use visual elements for the sake of looking good, not necessarily because they further the purpose of the site. Functional websites understand how visitors use the site to accomplish a goal. 

Hopefully, your website can have both and it can be visually striking, as well as functional. However, one way to kill conversions is to create a good-looking website that does not clearly direct visitors toward a specific action. You or your digital design team should be able to justify every element that makes it onto a web page in terms of its function. Do not waste resources on features that look cool but may ultimately confuse or distract visitors. 

Additionally, be specific with the wording of your Calls to Actions (CTAs). For example, “Get Started” is not as compelling as “Request a Free Consultation.” The language in the second case tells visitors exactly what they can expect. Website visitors crave certainty and predictability and are wary of taking an action if they are not sure what might happen. Be specific and don’t leave any room for doubt. 

Would you like to turn your website into a revenue-generating machine? Call us at 949-939-0772 or email us at and one of our knowledgeable and digitally-savvy team members will get right back to you. We know how to create new business.